|
Hi folks, I'm going to start by talking for a little while about something I think is relevant to Creatives. If that sounds interesting, great! If not, that's good too – you can skip down to the bottom for a tool that I've found useful and an upcoming Coworking Session. Try To Make Art Worth HatingAs a writer, a lot of what I hear about from executives is the need for “Voice”. “Find your Voice.” “Capture your Voice on the page.” “Make your Voice stand out.” It’s pretty much everywhere. It begins to sound like potential Voices are buzzing around like fireflies in your backyard and all you have to do is go outside with a glass jar and capture one. When I was considering starting a newsletter, I read some articles written by people with successful newsletters talking about what they did differently from everybody else with their not-as-successful newsletters – and one of the common themes was that the information everyone’s relaying is available from a lot of different sources. What people liked about receiving the successful newsletters is getting to hear the writer’s distinct Voice. So if Voice is so important, then what exactly is a Voice? Great question! mumble, mumble, cough… Well… I think we can all agree that we know it when we hear it. I’ve been part of a lot of writing groups at this point, and I’ve read many outlines of scripts. And one of the odd things I’ve seen so many times over the last couple of years is writers feeding their ideas into ChatGPT and asking it to chew up their thoughts and spit out an outline for them. And it does it. It purees the ideas into a pasty mush with an overall consistency of porridge. Nothing wrong with mush. Like a good mush every now and again. And in the mush, often it comes up with paragraphs like this one: "Brynne goes to the basement entrance. She pulls. The smell arrives before the door gives." Individually, these are all perfectly adequate sentences, it’s just a strange beat to include in an outline. A few months ago, I went to hear a living room reading of a play by one of my friend’s parents. (For now, let’s call them Friend X because it makes them sound like they’re a spy). Friend X’s parent was very pleased – they had cowritten their play with ChatGPT in just a few months! What a technological marvel, it’s like having their very own computer assistant. And… well, the play wasn’t awful. But okay, yeah, you could totally tell it was cowritten by a machine. How? There are many, many tells when AI writes an outline or script, but one of the things ChatGPT does consistently is talk about smells in different scenes. Television, film, plays, audio dramas, the medium doesn't matter, it's 'painting the scene' for you. How many times have you been to a theater where they were piping in the smell of baking bread or flowers? I’ve been to a lot of plays in my life (there were a few years where I was seeing 3-4 shows a week), and I actually have been to a few productions where they piped in smells. It was admittedly pretty cool. But most standard theaters don’t do that. Obviously the smell thing is not a big deal, but it’s indicative of a larger problem with ChatGPT writing – it often feels sterile and vague. If I used ChatGPT to write this newsletter, sure, maybe it would ‘cheapen’ the text because it would mean a human being didn’t put in the work to write down these words, but a bigger problem would be that it would lose a lot of my Voice. Why? Because having a Voice in your art (writing, drawing, acting, composing, whittling, fill-in-the-blank with your art here) is about having personality and having personality requires something to sound and feel personal and distinctive. And that means having something that isn’t so bland that everyone neutrally likes it. This is one of the reasons why capturing your Voice proves to be so much harder than hanging out in your yard with a net and a jar – it’s making art created with your specific individual point of view. Your perspective. And having a specific point of view means that frankly some people are going to dislike the art that you make. Probably a lot of people will. And somehow you have to make peace with the fact that when people dislike or even hate your art, they’re not hating you. They’re hating your art – which is created by you. With your distinct POV. So, okay, yes, in a way they actually are kind of hating you. But only kind of. They’re hating the art you’ve created and, even though it might not feel like it, that’s a good thing. Because it means that there’s something that isn’t mush there for them to hate. Tool of the WeekIf you struggle with keeping track of information (articles you've read and liked, personal statements you've written for various submissions, concepts you want to hold onto from courses you've taken, etc), I recommend checking out Obsidian. It stores notes and text files kind of like a personalized Wikipedia, so that you can link ideas to one another in the ways that make the most sense to you – which then makes it easier to find your notes the next time you go looking for them. It's not magic and I still struggle with keeping track of documents, but it helps a bit. Coworking SessionI'm going to be hosting a coworking session this week on Wednesday, September 24th from 1-4pm EST / 10am-1pm PST. Feel free to stop in and leave as it works best for your schedule. Here's the link: Meeting ID: 896 1878 8097 Passcode: 447438 Toby Tieger Right now, this newsletter has 14 subscribers. If you're thinking to yourself, "Hunh. Toby, that's not very many..." – you're totally right. (Though it is more than 10, so I still feel like I'm winning at The Internet Game.) It's partly because it's really important to me to collect email addresses in a consent-based way so that only people who actually want to get this newsletter receive it. If you know someone who you think might like getting this too, please forward the above link to them. |
Hi everyone, For anybody just joining – Welcome! I’m really glad to have you here. So I had a reading of one of my full-length plays last Friday and tomorrow I'm starting the 6-week in-person class that I'm teaching, which is all legitimately amazing. I feel extremely grateful to many, many people at this moment. Unfortunately, given how scattered my attention is that also means no ramble for this week. That said, there is a coworking session on Wednesday and the community bulletin board is...
Hi folks, For anybody just joining – Welcome! I’m really glad to have you here. A standard ramble for you all below, followed by a coworking session this week, the community bulletin board, and then some available free guides. So far, it seems like the Community Bulletin Board from last week was really a success! (Many thanks to everybody who reached out about it – it really helps when I hear from people what they think is working and useful.) In case you missed my spiel last week, my hope is...
Hi folks, For anybody just joining – Welcome! I’m really glad to have you here. No ramble this week. (Yes, I know I promised you all last week, it’s just that I’m working hard to get a script ready for a reading in a couple of weeks and prepping for the class I'm teaching, and I’m not nearly as good at multitasking as I would like.) However, I do have something new that I'm trying out which I think could potentially be useful – along with the weekly coworking sessions, I'm starting a new...